Government must stop requesting broad email search warrants, judge says

A district court judge is sending government prosecutors back to the drawing board when it comes to how they request warrants to search through suspects’ emails and other electronic communications. In an opinion and order rejecting a warrant request earlier this month, DC Magistrate Judge John Facciola said that the standard format of digital search warrant applications has been consistently leading to overbroad and unconstitutional requests .

“To be clear: the government must stop blindly relying on the language provided by the Department of Justice’s Searching and Seizing Computers and Obtaining Electronic Evidence in Criminal Investigations manual,” he writes. “By doing so, it is only submitting unconstitutional warrant applications.”

Facciola intends to start drilling in the message too. For months now, the court has been modifying warrant requests so that they comply with the Fourth Amendment, but Facciola now says that all further violating warrant requests will be denied with an explanation as to why they aren’t acceptable. Facciola draws on an earlier ruling to suggest how the government should be drafting its requests instead: rather than the government asking to perform the search itself, the court would like the company that hosts the suspect data to perform the search for them and then provide the results.

The earlier ruling also suggests a potentially critical addition: that the government waive its ability to use the plain view doctrine, which allows for the seizure of other evidence it might see while performing a more specific search.

Source: The Verge - Read the original article here

Author: Daily Tech Whip

This article is part of our 'News Tiles' service. The site is currently in Beta. When it is fully operational you will be able to search through and arrange the 'Tiles' to display a keyword, product or technology over your chosen time period. For example you would be able to display all of the leading tech articles on the new Kindle Fire, in one spot in real time. You will also have access to our own original reporting and analysis as well as a polished place to post your own thoughts & reviews here, amongst the Daily Tech Whip Community. Please let us know if you have any feedback via the contact form or via Twitter. Don't forget to come back next week and see our full site and claim your name and your own free tech blog.

Share This Post On