Panasonic SC-GA10 review: A smart speaker that fails to stand out

Alexa and Google Assistant have been taking over homes for a few years now, so it’s probably easier to name the companies that haven’t made a smart speaker. The options are seemingly endless. Audio gear that harnesses a virtual assistant comes in all shapes and sizes, with some making big claims about the quality of sound they get out of such small devices. Panasonic is doing just that with its $250 SC-GA10; however, the company’s promise of “premium hi-fi sound” failed to make a lasting impression.

A lot of smart speakers are round, cylindrical affairs, but Panasonic chose to go the boxy route with the SC-GA10. The speaker’s cube shape isn’t novel, but it’s different enough from a lot of the popular options (Echo, Google Home, etc) that it feels somewhat unique. Sure, it’s rather plain, but I kind of like that. T the GA10 blends in easily on a shelf thanks to its unassuming aesthetic.

Panasonic offers two color schemes for the SC-GA10: a mix of black and silver or white and silver. Both of those varieties are pretty standard fare for smart speakers. The SC-GA10’s look is simple with some Panasonic branding on the front and power and auxiliary jacks around back. There are also a few white lights on the front edge: one stays lit when the speaker is on, while others light up in a row whenever Google Assistant is active. Other than those few items, this speaker is basically a box that looks a bit like a miniature tower speaker.

Like many speakers, not just the smart ones, Panasonic put all of the physical controls up top. While this is the most convenient position, the height of the SC-GA10 poses some issues. All of the on-board controls are on a touch panel on the top of the speaker. There are controls for power, volume, muting the microphone, play/pause and several input options.

So far so good… until you try to make any tweaks when the speaker is sitting at eye level (or above) — like on a shelf. Unless the SC-GA10 is sitting in a spot where you have a full view of the top, you really have no idea what you’re tapping. Play/pause is pretty easy to remember because it’s alone in the center, and I quickly learned the location of the volume controls, but there are no raised dots or anything to let you know which of the features you’re close to. This may seem like a small thing for some people, but for me it was frustrating.

Sure, this is a voice controlled speaker and most of the time I just used spoken cues. For things like volume adjustments though, I prefer to make the change manually rather than relying on Google Assistant. A lot of smart speakers solve this with gesture controls, like Google Home and the Sony LF-S50G. There can be a bit of a learning curve with those as well, but you don’t have to worry as much about where you place those speakers since you don’t really need to see the top. As frustrating as the gestures were on the LF-S50G for me at first, I found myself wishing the Panasonic SC-GA10 had them.

When it comes to smart speakers, there’s a range of sound quality. While most aim simply to get the job done, others offer impressive audio in a compact device. Sonos One is a perfect example of the latter. With the SC-GA10, Panasonic promises “premium hi-fi sound” and tosses the word “supreme” around. But, I found the sound is mostly just… fine. It will certainly fill the void if you’re looking for a smart speaker, but if all you’re after is voice control, there are more affordable options like Google Home Mini, Echo or Echo Dot. Even the Sonos One is $50 cheaper and it offers both Alexa and better sound quality.

The Sony LF-S50G and the Panasonic SC-GA10.

While the audio on the SC-GA10 is crisp and clear, the EQ tuning is where Panasonic lost me. Across a range of genres, the sound lacks dynamics: the mid-range is overemphasized without the necessary amount of bass or treble. I noticed it most with bass-heavy genres like hip-hop. The low end is just muddy and lacks the punch or depth other speakers offer. At higher volumes, the EQ blends together and the overall audio quality is noticeably worse. There is a Panasonic app where you can make EQ tweaks, but in my experience, it didn’t offer much help. I’ll admit Sonos has spoiled me a bit, but the sound was noticeably better on the Sony LF-S50G too. With the claims Panasonic was making about the SC-GA10’s audio chops, I at least expected it to be comparable to the Sonos One. Instead, it’s just okay.

Despite the cloth-like material wrapping the entire top of the unit, the SC-GA10 isn’t a 360-degree speaker. Two tweeters are angled to the sides and there’s a single subwoofer, but the sound is beamed entirely out of the front. Other smart speakers blast tunes in all directions, but even though Panasonic’s smart speaker looks like it does the same, that’s not the case.

Of course, audio is just one piece of the equation here. Google Assistant is the main reason to consider the SC-GA10. I’m happy to report the smart features like voice control work just fine for the most part. There were times when it had trouble picking up my commands, but that was rare and usually happened when the speaker was blasting music at a considerable volume. My wife had trouble with the speaker hearing her spoken queries more often than not, but I had far less trouble. Of course, my voice was programmed into the Google Home app, but that didn’t make a difference on other speakers I’ve tested. The Sony LF-S50G even understood my three year old most of the time. Most of the time though, the SC-GA10 picked up my voice cues without issue. And thanks to the Google Home app, setting up the speaker only takes a couple minutes.

At $250, the SC-GA10 is at least $50 more than a lot of its competition. If you’re looking for Google Assistant alternatives, Google Home is $129 and Sony’s LF-S50G is $200. The Sonos One currently only works with Alexa, but at some point, it will also work with Assistant for $50 less than the SC-GA10. And of course, Amazon has a bunch of options at various price points if you don’t have a virtual assistant preference. Again, in terms over overall sound, Sony and Sonos are better options.

With all of the other options on the table, Panasonic’s SC-GA10 is a tough sell. Unless you really want touch controls on your smart speaker or just like the look of it, there are cheaper and better sounding devices to consider. I’ll admit I like the design of the SC-GA10, but when it comes to audio gear, you can’t make decisions based on looks alone. Sure, Google Assistant does an admirable job here, but the mediocre sound quality and high price makes this one of the less compelling additions to the smart speaker heap.

Source: Engadget - Read the full article here

Author: Daily Tech Whip

This article is part of our 'News Tiles' service. The site is currently in Beta. When it is fully operational you will be able to search through and arrange the 'Tiles' to display a keyword, product or technology over your chosen time period. For example you would be able to display all of the leading tech articles on the new Kindle Fire, in one spot in real time. You will also have access to our own original reporting and analysis as well as a polished place to post your own thoughts & reviews here, amongst the Daily Tech Whip Community. Please let us know if you have any feedback via the contact form or via Twitter. Don't forget to come back next week and see our full site and claim your name and your own free tech blog.

Share This Post On